How to Self-Administer an ICHRA: Employer Checklist
Yes, a small employer can self-administer an ICHRA, but it's a formal group health plan with real paperwork, not just a monthly stipend. To self-administer an ICHRA, you set up eligible employee classes and allowances, put the plan in writing, send a notice at least 90 days before the plan year, verify each employee's individual coverage, and process reimbursements with proof. This checklist walks through each step, using the federal rules as the guide. HealthCare.gov now calls these arrangements CHOICE arrangements.
Before you start: is self-administering a good fit?
Self-administration tends to work for small teams with simple setups: one or two employee classes, premium-only reimbursements and someone organized enough to handle monthly paperwork. It's a poor fit if you have a lot of turnover, several classes in different locations, or no one with the time to keep records. In those cases, a third-party administrator usually saves more than it costs. For the big-picture comparison with group coverage, start with our ICHRA guide for small businesses.
Either way, an ICHRA is a group health plan. For most private employers, that means ERISA rules apply to the HRA itself, even though the individual policies employees buy generally aren't ERISA plans.
Step 1: Set your employee classes and allowances
Decide who's eligible and how much each class gets. The federal rules allow classes such as full-time, part-time, seasonal, salaried, hourly, union employees, employees in a waiting period, and employees in different rating areas, and classes can be combined.
- Same terms within a class. Everyone in a class must get the ICHRA on the same terms. Amounts can increase with age or with the number of dependents covered.
- No double offers. You can't offer both a traditional group plan and an ICHRA to the same class.
- Minimum class sizes apply only if you offer a group plan to one class and an ICHRA to another. They don't apply if the ICHRA is your only health benefit.
- Covered expenses. Decide whether you'll reimburse premiums only, or premiums plus other medical expenses. Premium-only is simpler to administer.
Step 2: Put the plan in writing
Write a plan document that sets out eligibility, classes, allowance amounts, covered expenses, how employees submit claims, the opt-out rules and what happens when someone leaves. For ERISA-covered plans, employees also need a summary plan description that explains their benefits, rights and obligations in plain language. The Department of Labor generally requires participants to receive it within 90 days of becoming covered.
This is the step where most self-administering employers bring in help. A benefits attorney or administrator can draft documents that match your design, and that's usually far less expensive than fixing a problem later.
Step 3: Send the employee notice on time
Federal rules require a written notice at least 90 days before the start of each plan year. Employees who become eligible later, such as new hires, must get it no later than the date their HRA coverage can start. The notice explains the allowance, the requirement to have individual coverage, the opt-out right, and how the offer affects premium tax credits.
The Department of Labor publishes a model notice you can adapt. Using it is the easiest way to make sure nothing is missing. It also helps your employees, because the notice is what they rely on to enroll during their Special Enrollment Period. Our guide to ICHRA for employees is a plain-English companion you can share with your team.
Step 4: Verify coverage before you reimburse
Before paying anything, you need reasonable procedures to confirm that each participant, and each covered dependent, is or will be enrolled in individual health insurance coverage or Medicare for the plan year. The rules give examples: a document from the insurer or the Marketplace, such as an insurance card, or a written attestation from the employee.
Short-term health plans don't count as individual health insurance coverage, so they don't qualify an employee for reimbursement.
Step 5: Process reimbursements with proof
Each reimbursement request also needs substantiation. The federal rules allow a written attestation from the employee, which can be part of the request form, confirming they still have qualifying coverage. The federal agencies have published model attestation language.
A simple monthly routine looks like this:
- The employee submits a request with proof of the premium payment or expense and the coverage attestation.
- You check that the expense is covered by your plan and within the employee's allowance.
- You reimburse through payroll or a separate payment and record it.
- You keep the records, separately from personnel files.
If employees buy plans off the Marketplace, you can also let them pay any premium above the allowance with pre-tax salary reductions through a cafeteria plan (a Section 125 plan). That option isn't available for Marketplace plans, and if you offer it, it's treated as a term of the HRA, so it has to be offered to everyone in the class.
Step 6: Handle opt-outs and departures
Employees must be allowed to opt out of the ICHRA and waive future reimbursements once each plan year. This matters to them because, if your offer is considered unaffordable for them, opting out may let them claim a premium tax credit instead. Our guide to how ACA premium subsidies work explains the credit.
When an employee leaves, the plan must either have the remaining balance forfeited or let the employee permanently opt out and waive future reimbursements. Write your choice into the plan document.
Step 7: Keep up with ongoing compliance
- COBRA. HRAs are generally subject to COBRA, which applies to most private employers with 20 or more employees. A job loss or a cut in hours is generally a qualifying event.
- PCORI fee. HRAs are generally subject to this small federal fee, paid by the plan sponsor on IRS Form 720 by July 31 of the following year. The IRS lets HRA sponsors count one covered life per employee. The fee applies to plan years ending before October 1, 2029.
- Larger employers. If you have 50 or more full-time employees, including equivalents, the ICHRA also counts for the employer mandate's affordability rules, and you report it to the IRS on Form 1095-C.
- Annual review. Re-check classes, allowances and the notice date every year, and update the plan document when your design changes.
Where we come in
We help employers decide whether an ICHRA, a level-funded or fully-funded group plan or another option fits their team. Once an ICHRA is in place, we help employees choose individual plans that work with their allowance, at no cost to them. We don't draft legal documents, but we can point you to the right kind of help. For more resources, browse our small-business health benefits guides. Request a free review or call 541-731-4959.
Sources: eCFR: 26 CFR 54.9802-4 (ICHRA rules); U.S. Department of Labor: ICHRA model notice; IRS: PCORI fee questions and answers; Federal Register: 2019 HRA final rules.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Can a small business self-administer an ICHRA?
Yes. Federal rules do not require a third-party administrator. The employer still has to meet the ICHRA rules: offer the same terms within each employee class, put the plan in writing, send the notice on time, verify individual coverage and substantiate reimbursements. Many small employers design the plan themselves and get help with the legal documents.
When does the ICHRA notice have to go out?
At least 90 days before the start of each plan year. Employees who become eligible later, such as new hires, must receive it no later than the date their HRA coverage can start. The Department of Labor publishes a model notice employers can adapt.
How do I verify that employees have qualifying coverage?
Before reimbursing, use reasonable procedures to confirm each participant and covered dependent is enrolled in individual health insurance coverage or Medicare, such as a document from the insurer or the Marketplace or a written attestation. Each reimbursement request also needs substantiation, and an attestation on the request form can satisfy that. Short-term plans do not qualify.
Is an ICHRA subject to COBRA and the PCORI fee?
Generally, yes. HRAs are generally subject to COBRA, which applies to most private employers with 20 or more employees. HRAs are also generally subject to the PCORI fee, reported on IRS Form 720 by July 31 of the following year, and the IRS lets HRA sponsors count one covered life per employee.
Samuel Tripp
Founder and licensed independent insurance agent at Tripp Insurance Solutions in Tucson, Arizona. Licensed in AZ, TX, TN, WI, MI, ME, FL, PA, and CA. Samuel writes to make insurance decisions clearer and less stressful.
This content is for educational purposes only and is not medical, tax, or legal advice. This checklist summarizes federal rules for general information and is not legal or tax advice. Have an ERISA attorney, benefits administrator or tax professional review your plan documents and compliance. Plan availability, premiums, networks, and eligibility for premium tax credits and cost-sharing reductions vary by state, county, and household. Dates and figures reflect information published by HealthCare.gov, CMS, and the IRS as of the publication date and may change. For guidance specific to your situation, request a free review or speak with a licensed agent.
Thinking about an ICHRA for your team?
We will compare an ICHRA with group plan options for your business, then help your employees choose individual plans that fit their allowance. Request a review or call 541-731-4959.
Request a free coverage review